Good Morning: Saturday, September 08

As you can probably tell from the parades, the newsboys hawking EXTRA editions on the corner and the excited murmurs in the cafes, today is the 41st anniversary of the premier of Star Trek. I saw the first episode on my grandparent’s TV. Scared the holy Kahless out of me. I’ve been trying to come up with a Minnesota connection to Trek; they are few. I’m sure there’s more – any ideas?

No, Kevin Sorbo appearing in a series based on Gene Roddenberry’s ideas doesn’t count.

Here’s a sign of fall: the sound of high school football. While walking the dog last night I heard the chants of the kids on the field two blocks to the north – sounded like a hundred Spartans getting ready for war. You can understand why some people prefer the high school version to the professional variant. Those are our players.

What, and the Vikings aren’t?

Not to me. Not to many. Not everyone loves the Fair; not everyone loves the Vikings.

The Vikings start tomorrow. There was a time, long ago, when I cared. I still enjoy watching a game occasionally, but I don’t root. At some point the antics and attitudes of the players drove me off; it’s hard to enjoy the game if you don’t respect the players. (See also, politics.) It was amusing at first – when Keith Millard confronted police, dared them to shoot and said “my arms are more powerful than your guns,” it was so stupid you had to laugh: all that money and fame, and he's auditioning for the highlight reel of "Cops." You can get away with that if you have a big red S on your chest, but even Superman wouldn’t be so rude. Now the sense of power and entitlement seems to characterize the stars of the game. I’m the greatest. Worship me. Go to hell.

A few years ago I attended a game in the Metrodome, and wrote a column about the experience – it was okay, except for the profuse bleeding from the ears. The game was loud. Everything was loud. World War One called and asked them to turn it down. I got many derisive responses – hey, the noise is part of the fun, ya pansy. You can’t take a little volume, go back to, to, to that silly quiet-place thing. The library! Yeah, go back to the library. Haw. You’d think I’d demanded legislation requiring the Metrodome to turn it down to protect the tender timpanus of the unsuspecting patron who won a ticket in a bar raffle. I just said it was loud, and unpleasantly loud. Not loud in the rock-concert sense, or pointlessly loud like a bar that jacks up the music so everyone has to shout, but dumb loud. Big crashing slabs of noise dropped your head every 14 seconds, big sonic fists driven into your gut every time the ball was snapped.

I left the Metrodome knowing I’d lost interest in football for good - it felt like prefab corporate product that used interchangeable expendable men in holy local colors. The fact that it took years for me to realize this was probably an indication I hadn’t been paying close attention for a very long while - but football has a curious hold on the local imagination. We recall old grainy films of flinty Bud Grant barking orders in the snow, and think there’s still some connection to the Grand Old Tradition.

If you’re still a fan: good for you, and I hope they win. I hope you enjoy the season, and I promise not to clamber on the bandwagon if they manage to win three consecutive games. If it’s another losing season, our collective ego will suffer, and people from other municipalities will have the right to stare and laugh. Ha! Our hired athletes imported from other realms have accumulated more yards than your hired athletes, thus proving our municipality’s superiority in every area, from commerce to arts! Ha! As one local writer put it: It’s the winter of our discontent, except for the part about it being Fall. But it will also be the winter of our discontent in winter.

You’re welcome to it. The closest I’ll get to football will be the sound of the high school games, which drift into my backyard on autumn nights. I remember hearing the sounds the weeks after 9/11; it was a great comfort, an assertion, a proud shout in the face of worry and doubt. It’s not the music I hear, or the commercials, or the reminder that this First Down is brought to you by MegaBank – it’s the roar of the parents and siblings and friends, unamplified, unprompted, unsponsored. There’s a glow in the sky from the lights of the field. I wouldn’t miss the Vikings. I’d miss the sounds from the high school field. They sound like they mean it. This is their season. I hope they win.


Posted in   James_Lileks's blog | login to post comments

Interesting Minnesota/Star Trek Connection

James is right that the connections between the original Star Trek series and Minnesota are few. I did find one interesting one searching IMDB.com. This is from the IMDB entry for William Windom:

His great grandfather, politician William Windom (1827-1891), served in both the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate as a Republican for Minnesota; later became Secretary of the Treasury under James Garfield and Benjamin Harrison. His own character of Glen Morley in "The Farmer's Daughter" (1963) was also a congressman from Minnesota.

Recently reprised his "Star Trek" (1966) guest role as Commodore Matt Decker for the second episode of _Star Trek: New Voyages (2004)_.

I was not familiar with him, but he seems to be a very successful actor and is still working in his 80s.


MN on the final frontier

Here's a tenuous link for you. I'm a Minnesota author, and my first novel from Baen Books came out in the very same monthly batch as the first novel by James "Scotty" Doohan (doubtless with the help of a ghostwriter).

Doesn't count, does it? No.

Actually I'm just trying to remind people that I once had a publisher.


minnesota high school football

Some good accounts of high school football in Minnesota a century ago can be found in a couple of Maud Hart Lovelace's Betsy-Tacy books (hear me out before you groan ;-))

She grew up in Mankato and based her books on her real-life friends and people there. The high school ones in particular give a vivid account of "life back then." Even for being teen girls' books in the times they were published (1940's) they are intelligently written. Anyway, she describes going to out of town football games in 1909 and 1910 to places like Blue Earth--going in a group on the train, buying pastries (!) to take out to the field, walking up and down in the cold alongside the field because there were no bleachers. She talks about how the guys got beat up during the game, their faces smashed up, etc., in ways that parents would scream about now. She gives a blow-by-blow description of one game, and it has the feel James seems to be talking about.

"World War One called and asked them to turn it down"--great line :-)


They lost me, too

I used to follow football with some passion. Heck, I even cared about draft day. Not sure when it all changed for me, and I can't put my finger on why, but I don't give a rip any more.


Pro Football

Yeah, the "good ol' days" are long past as far as professional football goes, but that can be said of virtually any pro sport with the possible exception of hockey, and with the addition of teams from California to the league, the integrity of that fine institution won't be for long, if it hasn't begun it's decent already...
The success of pro wrestling seems to have had a profound effect on the NFL, and the demographic they target obviously no longer includes the likes of me (I'll be 48 in a month and have NEVER owned, via my kids or otherwise, a PS2 nor XBox nor even an Atari)...
The slide began with free-agency, the car salesmen were allowed full access to the players, and athletes began to be "groomed" for their place amongst the elite class shortly after birth...Manners and humilty, which used to be the greater part of character (with a few exceptions), no longer part of the curriculum...
I've started to watch college football, something I was never interested in, but seems to have a tenuous hold on integrity, at least compared. But greed is good, and the Great Buck Almighty dictates EVERYTHING nowadays.
OK yeah, I still watch the games...Glutton for punishment I guess...


Rooting For The Home Team?

I look forward to other brave new stances you might come up with... Mom/Apple-pie related perhaps?


Remember Those Orange Markers on the Field?

I, too, enjoy, or, I guess these days, enjoyed high school football; haven't been to a game since high school, oddly enough. While I didn't don a helmet, I was a little more active than most of the fans who turned up for a home game every Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday night.

For all four years at Augusta High School, I would sell programs for all of the varsity games played at home during the first half of each game. The programs were fifty cents a piece, and I was payed ten bucks a game; I made the most money in my freshman year.

The last two years at AHS, I also was on the field as part of the three-man chain crew for all 7th Grade, 8th Grade, Freshman, and JV home games, which were played Wednesdays and Thursdays during the season. Basically, whenever a referee wanted to determine a down, the three of us would rush out onto the field, pull the two orange markers as far as we could until the chain tightened, and the third man would flip the sign from one down to another, or, if it was still a certain down, wouldn't do a thing.

Then, we would rush back and avoid being killed by the players. All for fifteen bucks a game.

Those two jobs were the best jobs I had when I was in high school, and I'd do it again in a heartbeat.

Now, if only I could think of a reason to attend a game without a) being related to and/or knowing someone who is playing or b) working for the school district in any capacity, like I did in high school. Any suggestions?


re: MN author

You've got at least two fans for that novel (and a couple since); me in California, and my oldest daughter, in MN. Although she was already in MN (because that's where her husband and most of his relatives happen to live) before it was published, not moving there *because* she liked the story so well.

If you write some more, you've got at least two likely sales, if that helps.


Hey Lars

Hey Lars, I remember you...your first book was Erling's Word, right? I bought it...I'm sorry to say I can't give you my opinion on it, as I'm suffering from about a ten-year backlog on my fiction shelves and thus haven't quite gotten to it yet...


"I’ve been trying to come

"I’ve been trying to come up with a Minnesota connection to Trek; they are few. I’m sure there’s more – any ideas?"

Cripes, there are a LOT of connections between Trek and Minnesota. You missed the best one; Bruce Hyde, who played the legendary Ensign Kevin Riley, has taught at St. Cloud State for a rather long time. He's also artistic director at Theatre L'Homme Dieu, the well-respected summer program in Alexandria. Hates to be the focus of adoration from trekkies.

Speaking of Trekkies: Long Lake native Roger Nygard directed the documentary and St. Louis Park's Rich Kronfeld -- the original Dr. Sphincter and later known for being Wally Hotvedt on Comedy Central's "Let's Bowl" -- made an extended appearance in the documentary.

Honestly, Lileks, don't you do a minimal amount of research before pulling a posting out of your butt?


Thank you

I appreciate the support, but my novel-writing career, such as it is, isn't worth spending time on here.


James, you're right about

James, you're right about the NFL: it is pretty much just a corporate product now. There are no more Grants or Landrys; no more Bob Lillys or Jim Marshalls; no more showing the national anthem at each game on TV; no more showing the Super Bowl on a Sunday afternoon so KIDS COULD ACTUALLY WATCH IT!!. It's just product.

Same for college football now, too. If you want to fix college football, take the money out of it.


Latest image